forgettance

demographic deficit of 10 million people

antarchi's picture

at the same time as the Jewish Holocaust was happening in Europe, another Holocaust was happening in the world, namely the 1943/44 man-made Bengal Famine in British-ruled India. This atrocity took as many as 4 million lives and was associated with a 1940s demographic deficit of 10 million in Bengal. Satyajit Ray in his outstanding film “Distant Thunder” asserts that 5 million died. According to Amartya Sen, food was actually available there but cashed-up Calcutta, prosperous because of a war-time manufacturing boom, sucked food out of the rice-producing countryside. The price of rice increased 4-fold for a variety of reasons and in a free market, colonial economy and with a heartless, racist British administration, those who could not afford to buy rice simply starved.

they are seeking a place

antarchi's picture

The fascists destroyed our lives, so that even today we are unable to forget. Today we wander through the whole of Europe, searching for what the fascists took from us. Among us there are children who have Romani mothers and German fathers – children whose mothers were raped and came into the world that way children like J.S. and A. who wander with us as Roma and not as Germans. They also are seeking a place where they can stay and lead meaningful, dignified lives.

4,000 Roma gassed

antarchi's picture

On December 16th [1941], Himmler issued the order to have all Roma remaining in Europe deported to Auschwitz-Birkenau for extermination. On December 24th, Lohse gave the additional order that "The Gypsies should be given the same treatment as the Jews." At a party meeting on September 14th, 1942, Justice Minister Otto Thierack announced that "Jews and Gypsies must be unconditionally exterminated." On August 1st, 1944, four thousand Roma were gassed and cremated in a single action at Auschwitz-Birkenau, in what is remembered as Zigeunernacht.

ROMA HOLOCAUST - forgetting the victims

antarchi's picture

'Roma, commonly but inaccurately called Gypsies, were the only other population besides the Jews who were targeted for extermination on racial grounds in the Final Solution.'

Ian Hancock, Genocide of the Roma in the Holocaust


How many people today are aware that the Roma as a group was as much a victim - if not more so, proportionately - of the Nazi experiment as were the Jews? And how many people today would put their hands on their hearts and say that we should remember this for ever?

The shocking tragedy for those Roma who died as well as for those who miraculously survived, is that their suffering has not just been forgotten by humanity, it has been deliberately forgotten. We have not recognised their victimhood, we have hardly even acknowledged it, and we have done almost nothing to try to compensate - if that were ever possible. Worst of all, we have done nothing to prevent them from becoming victims all over again of exactly the same hatred and blind prejudice that drove the Nazi killers.

Nuggets to try to jog our non-existent memories...

See them all together here

remembrance and forgettance

antarchi's picture

This page is here because the Council of Europe (COE) asked for some 'background information' on Remembrance. 'Teaching Remembrance' is one of the Directorate of Education's pet projects, and one of the new themes for Compass, the Council's (so-called) human-rights-education manual.

the UK: doing its bit to remember

antarchi's picture

From the COE HR Commisioner's report On the Human Rights Situation of the Roma, Sinti and Travellers in Europe (2006)

On the basis of the Race Relations Act, the United Kingdom adopted a decree in 2001 ordering the immigration authorities to subject certain persons to “more rigorous examination than others in the same circumstances” on the basis of their nationality or ethnicity. The decree includes, in an annex, a list of such groups, among them the Roma. An immigration officer may, by reason of that person’s ethnic or national origin, detain the person pending his examination, decline to give the person’s notice of grant or refusal of leave to enter, and impose a condition or restriction on the person’s leave to enter the United Kingdom or on his temporary admission to the United Kingdom. Moreover, when the person is outside the United Kingdom, an immigration officer or the State Secretary may, by reason of that person’s ethnic or national origin, decline to give or refuse the person leave to enter before he arrives in the UK. This decree, which subjects persons to differentiated treatment solely on the basis of their nationality or ethnicity, is clearly in breach of the fundamental principle of non-discrimination and equality before the law, and should therefore be amended.

Syndicate content